This page is part of IGN’s Animal Crossing: New Horizons Wiki guide and describes everything you need to know about gift giving to your island’s residents!
Once you have completed the tasks of Jingle, you can start this section. But you can’t give a gift to a resident if it is not currently wrapped in a wrapping paper! You can use any wrapping paper you like, including festive wrapping paper. If you have nothing, talk to a villager and they will give you 3, but after that, you have to buy your own.
It is not possible to give a “wrong” gift to a resident! They will appreciate whatever you give, so Anhka will be happy to be given the dinosaur toy. After all, this is what the season is all about: you think about them!
Thanks for giving them a gift, your villagers will give you a gift of your own; It has nothing to do with what toy you give a villager and what toy you give in return. However they will always be in a different color from the toys you can buy from Nook’s Crony during the holidays. This is great for those who like to collect all types of Puppy Blush!